Charter of Contractual Fairness
On 1 July we launched our Charter of Contractual Fairness

We have heavily drawn the principles of contract fairness from the new consumer unfair contract protections laws. If it's fair for consumers, it's fair for small business people - the self-employed and independent contractors.

We are currently writing to Australian corporations asking them to commit to contract fairness in their dealings with small business people.
Our Campaigning
ICA's principal commitment is to lobby/advocate on small business issues. Here are our current campaigns:
Unfair Contract Protections
ICA says "extend unfair contract protections for consumers to small business". Our overview is here.
Stop Sham Contracts
ICA supports the prevention of sham contracts. We monitor what's happening with them. Our summary links are here.
Stop Phoenix Companies
Here's our commentary and some further links on the Phoenix problem.
Defend Contractor Tax
ICA has long fought to protect fair contractor tax laws.
Election Face-off 2010
The federal election was held on on 21 August 2010. ICA was active in assessing the policies of the ALP and the Coalition. Here's our comparative summary of the parties' policies just before the election.
Australian military aircraft (JSF). Bad deal?
Australia's decision to buy the Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) as the backbone of our air defence is under attack. Is this a bad procurement and contract management stuff-up? We've summarised the arguments and included some useful videos.

We Oppose Workplace Bullying
ICA opposes attempts by construction unions to bully their way on to work sites. Here are the issues from 2010:
Overview
Union violence on Westgate
Unions make threats

Laughing lawyers
You'll be amazed by the 'slips' that some lawyers make in court.
Watching Global Economies
Watching the USA
The US economy appears to be in recession. At the very least, we're getting very mixed signals about what's happening. Click here for a rundown on some of the best links we've found.
Watching China
China has just passed Japan as the world's second largest economy. It could become the largest global economy by 2030. We're maintaining a watching brief on the Chinese economy here.
Watching Goldman Sachs
Rolling Stone magazine has blown the lid on Goldman Sachs:
Article 1 [July 2009]
Article 2 [April 2010]
Article 3 [May 2010]
Central Banks on Debt
Since mid-May, central banks have been worried about sovereign debt. Click here for a list of useful links and summaries.
What the Pessimists said (January 2010)
We've brought together some pessimistic views about economics and likely economic trends in 2010:
US toxic loans
'US as sick as Greece'
Ken Phillips's summary
An 'IMF' perspective
Predicting 2010
Government debt a giant ponzi scheme?


Click to enlarge.

Ken Phillips on the debt equation

Industry/Retail super funds must come out
The Cooper Review into superannuation says the big funds are not disclosing enough and must be forced to do so. This is vital. See Chapter 4.

Here's why workers' money is at risk if disclosure is not enforced.
Look after your retirement
The Cooper Review of superannuation says Self Managed Super Funds are good and need little change to existing arrangements. This is welcome. See Chapter 8.

The Report also seems to have stopped the attack against SMSF's.
Understanding "Us": Self-employed People
ICA is committed to quality research to understand self-employed people.

6 July 2010: We released a unique research report made possible by an unusual collaborative effort. The report shatters many preconceived beliefs about 'us'; small and micro-business people. We believe it has global implications.

Main points and commentary
Summary
Full report.

20 July 2010: Here's further research from Flying Solo:
Report Summary; Full report and from Kelly Services: Report. And here's a comparative chart of our own.

Taking the con out of contractor


If your business doesn't use individual contract engineers, marketers, accountants, cleaners or any other form of contractor, you can happily skip this article. However, if you do, it's important to understand what has just happened to the law governing this kind of work.

Late last week (8 October) the Federal Court released the first decision on a sham contract prosecution in Australia.

Sham contract legislation was created by the Howard government in 2006. It's a provision now of the Fair Work Act (FWA). The Howard legislation was certainly a global first and is possibly still the only law of its type in the world.

The idea to outlaw sham contracts arose at the International Labour Organisation (ILO) in 2006 when it declared self-employment to be legitimate. The ILO also called on governments to prevent sham arrangements, which Howard implemented. A sham contract exists according to the FWA and the ILO if someone misrepresents what is actually an employment arrangement, passing it off as an independent contractor arrangement. Conceptually it involves a low level form of (non-criminal) fraud. Nonetheless, it is still a con.

The Fair Work Ombudsman is charged with investigating and prosecuting shams, but in more than two years, it appears it hasn't found a case where a prosecution could be concluded. This first prosecution was conducted by the construction union the CFMEU against Nubrick Pty Ltd.

In this case a manager had engaged two workers in a brick factory as 'independent contractors.' It seems that both the manager and the workers believed that having an Australian Business Number (ABN) secured their self-employment status. The judge however found the workers were in fact employees of Nubrick.

The CFMEU asserted that the finding of employment was enough to prove a sham; involving a potential hefty fine. The judge disagreed, ruling that for a sham to exist under the FWA, there must be an intent to deceive or misrepresent. In this case the manager at Nubrick and the workers genuinely believed that an ABN was sufficient for self-employment to exist. An error had been made and an error does not constitute a sham.

But the CFMEU is not happy. In their often-used class-warfare language they claim the decision is giving the "green light to bosses". They are calling for the FWA to be changed. But they'll need to convince the ILO to change its position as well.

The judge's decision drew on significant legal precedent in giving judicial interpretation to the FWA sham contract provisions. It's a very sensible decision.

The law is quite settled on what constitutes the difference between an independent contractor and employment contract. At Independent Contractors of Australia we call it a 'swinging pendulum' test (for a summary of the subtests, click here).

But in practical application there can be confusion. Understanding the subtests and applying them consistently requires managerial knowledge and attention to detail. I've looked at and advised on lots of arrangements and the level of accurate knowledge by Australian managers is low. They persistently get it wrong even if the intent is good.

Most common misunderstandings relate to the use of ABNs, which has been highlighted with this Nubrick case. Another myth, particular held by accountants, is the supposed 80/20 rule which is in fact irrelevant to common law. Too many managers and businesses rely on a lawyer's standard form contract in a 'set and forget' process. Unfortunately this doesn't help because the courts will always 'look through' the written to find truth in the behaviours of the parties.

It is management systems which are the key and in it's in this area where there's a big need to lift performance.

Over the last several years, tax and general law have become progressively settled on the independent contractor issue. Increasingly there's little excuse for implementing bad or incorrect contracts.

People might make genuine errors which the courts will understand. But at some point courts will become impatient with real or particularly feigned ignorance on matters which businesses should make themselves aware of. Sham contract convictions are inevitable if businesses fail to upgrade their behavior.

This is not something that can be ignored. The self-employed make up 28 percent of the private sector workforce. It's normal now for independent contractors to provide services to all sorts of businesses. Big holes in corporate operations would emerge if independent contractors were not utilised. It's necessary, however, to engage the sector properly.

That's the main lesson from this first sham contract prosecution. Expect more activity on this issue.

From the Business Spectator, October 2009.

Your Thoughts

We're keen to hear what you think of Ken's articles. If you'd like to make a contribution, please send us an email here.